Skip to content
  • Students & Alumni
    • Overview
    • Career Services
    • Alumni Relations
    • Student Support
    • Graduate Resource Library
  • News
  • Events
    • Events Calendar
    • Luskin Summit
    • Luskin Lecture Series
    • California Policy Briefing
    • Commencement
  • Students & Alumni
    • Overview
    • Career Services
    • Alumni Relations
    • Student Support
    • Graduate Resource Library
  • News
  • Events
    • Events Calendar
    • Luskin Summit
    • Luskin Lecture Series
    • California Policy Briefing
    • Commencement
Giving
  • Academics
    Departments
    • Public Policy
    • Real Estate Development
    • Social Welfare
    • Undergraduate Program
    • Urban Planning
    • Public Policy
    • Real Estate Development
    • Social Welfare
    • Undergraduate Program
    • Urban Planning
    Graduate Programs
    • Master of Public Policy (MPP)
    • Master of Real Estate Development (MRED)
    • Master of Social Welfare (MSW)
    • Master of Urban and Regional Planning (MURP)
    • PhD in Social Welfare
    • PhD in Urban Planning
    • Master of Public Policy (MPP)
    • Master of Real Estate Development (MRED)
    • Master of Social Welfare (MSW)
    • Master of Urban and Regional Planning (MURP)
    • PhD in Social Welfare
    • PhD in Urban Planning
    Undergraduate Programs
    • BA in Public Affairs
    • Minor in Urban and Regional Studies
    • Minor in Gerontology
    • Minor in Public Affairs
    • BA in Public Affairs
    • Minor in Urban and Regional Studies
    • Minor in Gerontology
    • Minor in Public Affairs
    Professional Certificates
    • Data Analytics Certificate
    • Data Analytics Certificate
  • Admissions
    Program Specific Admissions
    • Public Policy
    • Real Estate Development
    • Social Welfare
    • Urban Planning
    • Undergraduate Program
    • Public Policy
    • Real Estate Development
    • Social Welfare
    • Urban Planning
    • Undergraduate Program
  • Faculty
    Our Faculty
    • All Faculty
    • Public Policy
    • Real Estate Development
    • Social Welfare
    • Urban Planning
    • All Faculty
    • Public Policy
    • Real Estate Development
    • Social Welfare
    • Urban Planning
    Leadership
    • Our Dean
    • Board of Advisors
    • Faculty Executive Committee
    • Our Dean
    • Board of Advisors
    • Faculty Executive Committee
  • Research Centers
    • Agile Visual Analytics Lab (AVAL):

      Uses data visualization to improve decision-making for family and child services.

    • Berggruen Governance Index

      Evaluates the quality of political governance and democracy worldwide.

    • Center for Neighborhood Knowledge (CNK)

      Specializes in spatial analysis of socioeconomic disparities in neighborhoods.

    • Center for Policy Research on Aging (CPRA)

      Explores the societal and policy implications of an aging population.

    • Agile Visual Analytics Lab (AVAL):

      Uses data visualization to improve decision-making for family and child services.

    • Berggruen Governance Index

      Evaluates the quality of political governance and democracy worldwide.

    • Center for Neighborhood Knowledge (CNK)

      Specializes in spatial analysis of socioeconomic disparities in neighborhoods.

    • Center for Policy Research on Aging (CPRA)

      Explores the societal and policy implications of an aging population.

    • Institute of Transportation Studies (ITS)

      A national leader in transportation policy and mobility research.

    • Institute on Inequality and Democracy

      Advances scholarship addressing displacement and dispossession in Los Angeles and beyond.

    • Latin American Cities Initiative

      Connects urban planning and policy networks across the Americas.

    • Latino Policy & Politics Institute (LPPI)

      Addresses policy challenges facing Latinos and communities of color.

    • Institute of Transportation Studies (ITS)

      A national leader in transportation policy and mobility research.

    • Institute on Inequality and Democracy

      Advances scholarship addressing displacement and dispossession in Los Angeles and beyond.

    • Latin American Cities Initiative

      Connects urban planning and policy networks across the Americas.

    • Latino Policy & Politics Institute (LPPI)

      Addresses policy challenges facing Latinos and communities of color.

    • Lewis Center for Regional Policy Studies

      Researches housing, transportation, and economic development in Southern California.

    • Los Angeles Education Research Institute (LAERI)

      Collaborates with schools to improve educational outcomes for L.A. students.

    • Luskin Center for Innovation (LCI)

      Focuses on environmental policy, clean energy, and climate justice.

    • UCLA Voting Rights Project

      The flagship project for voting rights litigation and policy research.

    • Lewis Center for Regional Policy Studies

      Researches housing, transportation, and economic development in Southern California.

    • Los Angeles Education Research Institute (LAERI)

      Collaborates with schools to improve educational outcomes for L.A. students.

    • Luskin Center for Innovation (LCI)

      Focuses on environmental policy, clean energy, and climate justice.

    • UCLA Voting Rights Project

      The flagship project for voting rights litigation and policy research.

    All Research Centers
  • Outcomes
Home / A System That Threatens Rights of the Unhoused

A System That Threatens Rights of the Unhoused

tents in park, with sign reading "House Keys Not Handcuffs"

Posted in

  • Luskin in the News

Published on

  • May 27, 2022
  • homelessness, housing justice, Institute on Inequality and Democracy, Los Angeles, shelter, tenants, unhoused

Share this Article

A New Republic article on Los Angeles homelessness policies that led to the 2021 sweep of an encampment at Echo Park Lake cited UCLA Luskin faculty members Ananya Roy and Mark Vestal. The two scholars described a shelter system that often violates the rights of unhoused individuals. Roy, director of the UCLA Luskin Institute on Inequality and Democracy and author of a report on the fallout from the Echo Park Lake eviction, said residents of interim housing face “a constant stripping of rights in the way that in prison you’re stripped of your rights.” Before entering interim housing, residents must testify that “no tenancy is created,” effectively denying them hard-fought rights associated with being a tenant, said Vestal, an assistant professor of urban planning. He added that politicians and police often deploy the language of mental illness, “justifying the shelter system as a medical intervention,” rather than confronting the public policies that deprive people of dignified housing.

Read the article

 
Faculty Mentioned in this Article
Marques Vestal

Marques Vestal

Assistant Professor of Urban Planning

Marques Vestal is an Assistant Professor of Urban Planning and Critical Black Urbanism. He serves as a Faculty Advisor for...

Ananya-Roy-2x3

Ananya Roy

Professor of Urban Planning, Social Welfare, and Geography

Ananya Roy is Professor of Urban Planning, Social Welfare, and Geography and The Meyer and Renee Luskin Chair in Inequality...

Related Articles

Group of people walking together in a fenced and gated ICE detention center.

Fugitive Sanctuaries: Ananya Roy on Migration, Solidarity, and Sanctuary

February 13, 2026
Luskin in the News
Luskin professor examines how migrant movements, not states, create safety in the face of structural violence....
Read More
box with four headshots

Welcoming the 2026 UCLA Activists-in-Residence

February 11, 2026
Luskin's Latest Blog
The five-month residency provides time to reflect and recharge, envision new projects, and connect with UCLA...
Read More
black background with book title and red spotted house

On Migrant Crackdowns and Empty Humanitarian Rhetoric

October 31, 2025
Luskin in the News
UCLA Luskin’s Ananya Roy explores themes in the recently published book "Beyond Sanctuary: The Humanism of...
Read More
Downtown LA just after sunset during blue hour, captured from a helicopter point of view with lighted City Hall building.

UCLA Grants Deepen Ties to the L.A. Community

March 17, 2025
For Faculty
Projects by Luskin faculty will build collaboration among scholars, students and local partners....
Read More
"Dawn Blockade at Echo Park Lake," a mural by Jed Parriott, is featured at the "Tents and Tenants" exhibit.

It Is Only Possible to Fail If We Forget

February 19, 2025
For Faculty
Exhibit captures impact of the Echo Park Lake tent community, with lessons for future social movements....
Read More
headshots of three women and a man

UCLA Public Interest Research Awards Recognize Tenant Advocacy Project

August 14, 2024
Luskin's Latest Blog
Scholars from the UCLA Luskin Institute on Inequality and Democracy spearheaded the team that created the...
Read More
MVfencephoto1

Vestal on the Meaning of Fences in Los Angeles

July 30, 2024
Luskin in the News
Urban planning expert says neighborhood fortifications reflect thinking from different eras, and different fears....
Read More
Black woman wearing glasses speaks from a podium with a UCLA Luskin backdrop behind her

Resisting the ‘New McCarthyism’ on College Campuses and Beyond

February 20, 2024
For Faculty
In a UCLA lecture, historian Barbara Ransby warns of 'a war over ideas, over facts, over...
Read More
woman at podium with image projected on large screen behind her that shows activists' pictures and names|four of this year's activists face the camera with backdrops of sponsors behind them|a dozen people gathered in advance of a group photo laugh while one of them holds a dog in the foreground|the two activists pose for a photo in front of a backdrop for the UCLA Luskin Institute on Inequality and Democracy|woman with dark curly hair is shown in profile at a podium while speaking|African American man gestures as he speaks with a microphone in hand

UCLA Hosts Its Largest Activist-in-Residence Cohort

January 31, 2024
Alumni
Five advocates for social change will be on campus through May to ‘turn the university inside...
Read More
Man setting up tent in street in front of police officers

A ‘Generation-Altering Moment’ in the Homelessness Crisis

January 25, 2024
Luskin in the News
UCLA Luskin's Marques Vestal says a Supreme Court case on laws targeting the unhoused could lead...
Read More
Man on bed in hotel room, typing on laptop

Roy on Repeated Displacement of L.A.’s Unhoused Population

October 19, 2023
Luskin in the News
The sweep of an encampment in Van Nuys, part of a city program to address homelessness,...
Read More
man with white beard wearing hat

Essays Capture Legacy of L.A. Historian Mike Davis

October 11, 2023
Luskin's Latest Blog
The author, urbanist and chronicler of L.A. history is the subject of a series of essays...
Read More
Learn more about UCLA Luskin

Find contact information and get answers to your questions.

Contact Us

Public Affairs Building
337 Charles E. Young Drive East
Los Angeles, California 90095

Linkedin Youtube Instagram Facebook X-twitter
Campus Resources
  • Map, Directions, Parking
  • Directory
  • Academic Calendar
  • Careers
  • Map, Directions, Parking
  • Directory
  • Academic Calendar
  • Careers
School Resources
  • About
  • Our Dean
  • Administration
  • Board of Advisors
  • Contact Us
  • Visit Us
  • About
  • Our Dean
  • Administration
  • Board of Advisors
  • Contact Us
  • Visit Us
© 2026 Regents of the University of California
  • Emergency
  • Accessibilty
  • Privacy & Terms of Use
  • Emergency
  • Accessibilty
  • Privacy & Terms of Use
Facebook Instagram Linkedin X-twitter Youtube Threads
Academics
Departments
  • Public Policy
  • Real Estate Development
  • Social Welfare
  • Undergraduate Program
  • Urban Planning
  • Public Policy
  • Real Estate Development
  • Social Welfare
  • Undergraduate Program
  • Urban Planning
Graduate Programs
  • Master of Public Policy (MPP)
  • Master of Real Estate Development (MRED)
  • Master of Social Welfare (MSW)
  • Master of Urban and Regional Planning (MURP)
  • PhD in Social Welfare
  • PhD in Urban Planning
  • Master of Public Policy (MPP)
  • Master of Real Estate Development (MRED)
  • Master of Social Welfare (MSW)
  • Master of Urban and Regional Planning (MURP)
  • PhD in Social Welfare
  • PhD in Urban Planning
Undergraduate Programs
  • BA in Public Affairs
  • Minor in Urban and Regional Studies
  • Minor in Gerontology
  • Minor in Public Affairs
  • BA in Public Affairs
  • Minor in Urban and Regional Studies
  • Minor in Gerontology
  • Minor in Public Affairs
Professional Certificates
  • Data Analytics Certificate
  • Data Analytics Certificate
Admissions
Program Specific Admissions
  • Public Policy
  • Real Estate Development
  • Social Welfare
  • Urban Planning
  • Undergraduate Program
  • Public Policy
  • Real Estate Development
  • Social Welfare
  • Urban Planning
  • Undergraduate Program
Faculty
Our Faculty
  • All Faculty
  • Public Policy
  • Real Estate Development
  • Social Welfare
  • Urban Planning
  • All Faculty
  • Public Policy
  • Real Estate Development
  • Social Welfare
  • Urban Planning
Leadership
  • Our Dean
  • Board of Advisors
  • Faculty Executive Committee
  • Our Dean
  • Board of Advisors
  • Faculty Executive Committee
Research Centers
  • Agile Visual Analytics Lab (AVAL):

    Uses data visualization to improve decision-making for family and child services.

  • Berggruen Governance Index

    Evaluates the quality of political governance and democracy worldwide.

  • Center for Neighborhood Knowledge (CNK)

    Specializes in spatial analysis of socioeconomic disparities in neighborhoods.

  • Center for Policy Research on Aging (CPRA)

    Explores the societal and policy implications of an aging population.

  • Agile Visual Analytics Lab (AVAL):

    Uses data visualization to improve decision-making for family and child services.

  • Berggruen Governance Index

    Evaluates the quality of political governance and democracy worldwide.

  • Center for Neighborhood Knowledge (CNK)

    Specializes in spatial analysis of socioeconomic disparities in neighborhoods.

  • Center for Policy Research on Aging (CPRA)

    Explores the societal and policy implications of an aging population.

  • Institute of Transportation Studies (ITS)

    A national leader in transportation policy and mobility research.

  • Institute on Inequality and Democracy

    Advances scholarship addressing displacement and dispossession in Los Angeles and beyond.

  • Latin American Cities Initiative

    Connects urban planning and policy networks across the Americas.

  • Latino Policy & Politics Institute (LPPI)

    Addresses policy challenges facing Latinos and communities of color.

  • Institute of Transportation Studies (ITS)

    A national leader in transportation policy and mobility research.

  • Institute on Inequality and Democracy

    Advances scholarship addressing displacement and dispossession in Los Angeles and beyond.

  • Latin American Cities Initiative

    Connects urban planning and policy networks across the Americas.

  • Latino Policy & Politics Institute (LPPI)

    Addresses policy challenges facing Latinos and communities of color.

  • Lewis Center for Regional Policy Studies

    Researches housing, transportation, and economic development in Southern California.

  • Los Angeles Education Research Institute (LAERI)

    Collaborates with schools to improve educational outcomes for L.A. students.

  • Luskin Center for Innovation (LCI)

    Focuses on environmental policy, clean energy, and climate justice.

  • UCLA Voting Rights Project

    The flagship project for voting rights litigation and policy research.

  • Lewis Center for Regional Policy Studies

    Researches housing, transportation, and economic development in Southern California.

  • Los Angeles Education Research Institute (LAERI)

    Collaborates with schools to improve educational outcomes for L.A. students.

  • Luskin Center for Innovation (LCI)

    Focuses on environmental policy, clean energy, and climate justice.

  • UCLA Voting Rights Project

    The flagship project for voting rights litigation and policy research.

All Research Centers
Outcomes
Common Search Terms

Results will show as you type.